
As a bond manager and a fan of Norwich City, I have a natural predisposition towards misery. Yet despite this, there is one topic on which I am much more cheerful than the wider consensus.
In our discussions with our clients, we have repeatedly highlighted the potential downside risks in private credit. We think the combination of too much capital chasing too few opportunities, terrible underwriting, over-concentration by sector and a ‘mark-your-own-homework’ approach to default reporting has created a nasty dynamic.
So far, so gloomy. But where I am far more cheerful than the consensus is on what this means for high yield. The narrative seems to be that if private credit is the epicentre of questionable lending, then it is unlikely that high yield is sufficiently far removed to avoid the fallout.
I disagree. And recent data on leverage from Morgan Stanley highlights how different the two asset classes are:
So leverage within high yield is meaningfully lower than it is in private credit.
Remember, the danger posed by leverage increases at an accelerating rate as debt rises. Leverage increasing from 0.5x to 1.5x is not overly concerning. But if it increases from 4.0x to 5.0x, then the level of risk could double. As such, the jump from 3.6x leverage seen in high yield to 5.7x private credit indicates a massive increase in risk and a reduction in quality.
What impact does all that leverage have on default rates in private credit? As a recent piece by Bloomberg neatly put it: it depends on who you ask.

Source: J.P. Morgan, 24 June 2026, 2026 Mid-Year Outlook and Bloomberg, 17 September 2026, Private Credit Defaults Are 1%, 6% or 19%, Depending Who You Ask
Bloomberg’s report shows that estimated default rates in private credit range from 3.3% (KBRA), to 6.3% (Fitch) up to as high as 19% for business development companies BDCs (PIMCO)2. Why this disparity? Unfortunately, lots of things that look an awful lot like defaults – and are considered as such by the high-yield market – are not recorded as defaults by the companies who run private credit funds.
Let’s take the highest estimated default rate, from PIMCO3. In its attempt to calculate a true default rate, it counted:
1. Defaults on payment
2. Loans marked as non-accruing (where a private credit firm has acknowledged it is unlikely to get its money back so has stopped accruing interest that is building up)
3. Converting contractual cash payments into payments in kind (PIKs) (where a borrower can’t pay its liabilities in cash but will instead ‘repay’ its lenders with more IOUs).
4. Loan-maturity extensions (pushing back maturity dates is the ‘extend and pretend’ approach some banks took to real-estate lending at the time of the GFC).
5. Debt-to-equity swaps
All of these might perfectly reasonably be defined as defaults, and in public bond markets they usually would be.
Although we thank PIMCO for trying to establish the ‘true’ default rate in private credit, we’re happy that we don’t need to estimate ‘true’ default rates in high yield. Markets and public rating agencies already do that for us. When a high-yield issuer defaults, everybody knows about it. Ratings agencies record it. Index providers respond. Investors remember it. The event becomes part of the historical record. There is no room for extending and pretending.
Yet despite this far stricter approach, default rates in high yield have been – and are expected to remain – far lower than in private credit. (J.P. Morgan expects a default rate of 1.75% in the US high-yield market this year.4)
Put simply, high yield is less highly levered than private credit and it should be well insulated should there be a wave of defaults in private credit. But it would be nice if Norwich would stop conceding quite so many goals.
Read more about recent happenings in high-yield: High Yield Happenings: No FOMO - Investors in high yield should not fear missing the AI boom | Artemis Funds
1. Morgan Stanley Research Gross Leverage in US Leveraged Credit as at Q1 2026
2. Bloomberg, 17 September 2026, Private Credit Defaults Are 1%, 6% or 19%, Depending Who You Ask
3. PIMCO, 24 August 2026, The Credit Market Lens: Narrowing the Visibility Gap in Defaults
4. J.P. Morgan, 24 June 2026, 2026 Mid-Year Outlook
FOR PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS AND/OR QUALIFIED INVESTORS AND/OR FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARIES ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH OR BY PRIVATE INVESTORS.
CAPITAL AT RISK. All financial investments involve taking risk and the value of your investment may go down as well as up. This means your investment is not guaranteed and you may not get back as much as you put in. Any income from the investment is also likely to vary and cannot be guaranteed.
This is a marketing communication. Before making any final investment decisions, and to understand the investment risks involved, refer to the fund prospectus (or in the case of investment trusts, Investor Disclosure Document and Articles of Association), available in English, and KIID/KID, available in English and in your local language depending on local country registration, available in the literature library.
The intention of Artemis’ ‘investment insights’ articles is to present objective news, information, data and guidance on finance topics drawn from a diverse collection of sources. Content is not intended to provide tax, legal, insurance or investment advice and should not be construed as an offer to sell, a solicitation of an offer to buy, or a recommendation for any security or investment by Artemis or any third-party. Potential investors should consider the need for independent financial advice. Any research or analysis has been procured by Artemis for its own use and may be acted on in that connection. The contents of articles are based on sources of information believed to be reliable; however, save to the extent required by applicable law or regulations, no guarantee, warranty or representation is given as to its accuracy or completeness. Any forward-looking statements are based on Artemis’ current opinions, expectations and projections. Articles are provided to you only incidentally, and any opinions expressed are subject to change without notice. The source for all data is Artemis, unless stated otherwise. The value of an investment, and any income from it, can fall as well as rise as a result of market and currency fluctuations and you may not get back the amount originally invested.
High Yield Happenings: Reasons to be cheerful despite worries about private credit